For Immediate Release


March 26, 2012

Mary Boyle

(202) 736-5770




Powerful Corporate Interests Used the American Legislative Exchange Council to Undermine the Affordable Care Act




MEMO TO: Interested reporters and editors

FROM: Mary Boyle


For the past three years, the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC) and its corporate backers have engineered a sophisticated and coordinated campaign to undermine the Affordable Care Act (ACA) in state houses across the country. Not surprisingly, the corporations behind ALEC include the health care industry and powerful pharmaceutical interests. Notable corporate members include, Wellpoint, Pfizer, and GlaxoSmithKline, and the industry’s trade association, PhARMA.


According to the National Conference of State Legislatures, the ALEC Freedom of Choice in Health Care Act[1], a model bill ALEC boasts has been introduced in 44 states since 2009, has helped drive state-based legislative challenges to the ACA.[2] A December 2010 statement from Christie Herrera, ALEC’s Health and Human Services Task Force Director, stated: “ALEC’s Freedom of Choice in Health Care Act is spreading throughout the country and giving the states the leverage they need to bring about challenges to ObamaCare.”[3]


ALEC is also involved in state and national legal challenges to the ACA, including cases being argued this week in the United States Supreme Court. ALEC’s brief in the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals case,[4] State of Florida and National Federation of Independent Business v. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, was cited in the majority opinion that found aspects of the ACA unconstitutional[5]. This case is now pending before the Supreme Court, where ALEC has also filed an amicus brief.[6] While ALEC describes its filings as submitted on behalf of its legislators,” it omits mention that its funding is derived almost entirely from private corporations and foundations, including a large section of the private health care industry.


At ALEC “task force meetings,” corporate representatives sit alongside legislators, introducing and voting on ALEC model bills. The Freedom of Choice in Health Care Act was passed by ALEC’s Health and Human Services task force in December 2008. Documents reviewed by Common Cause indicate the task force included pharmaceutical giants GlaxoSmithKline, Eli Lilly, Bayer, Pfizer, and Johnson & Johnson, along with PhRMA, the industry’s trade association; also included were health insurance providers WellPoint, United Health Group, CVS Caremark and Amerigroup, plus non-health related organizations including Reynolds American Inc., Wal-Mart and the Koch brothers-sponsored Heartland Institute.


On its website, ALEC celebrates its success in challenging the ACA in state houses and the courts.[7] But its mischaracterization of the drive as coming from state legislators alone is disingenuous and deserves attention.



Here is a table of states where the ALEC Freedom of Choice in Health Care Act has been introduced, where it has passed, and noting where the bill sponsor is known to be a member of ALEC.








FCC's Reported Capitulation around Open Internet Protections is a Major Step Backward - April 24, 2014

Secret, Outside Money Will Dominate N.H. Senate Contest Unless Candidates Adopt "People's Pledge" - April 18, 2014

Common Cause Hails New York's Adoption of National Popular Vote - April 16, 2014

Common Cause Disappointed by Appeals Court's Rejection of Filibuster Suit - April 15, 2014

On Tax Day, IRS Chief Delivers Some Good News - April 15, 2014

400,000 Join Chorus of Protest Against Comcast-Time Warner Cable Merger - April 9, 2014

Democracy Advocates Urge Shaheen, Brown to Get Serious About 'People's Pledge' - April 7, 2014

Again, U.S. Supreme Court Decides Against Democracy - April 2, 2014

Common Cause Lauds FCC Move to Bolster Independent, Local Media - March 31, 2014

Presidential Public Financing System Needs Strengthening, Not Dismantling - March 11, 2014

Group Tied to President Obama Opened White House Doors for Major Donors - March 5, 2014

IRS Must End Misuse of Nonprofits to Hide Political Spending But Proposed Rules As Drafted Need Major Revisions, Common Cause Asserts - February 28, 2014

Common Cause Statement on House Passage of HR 3865, to Preserve the Social Welfare Tax Loophole for Political Non-Profit Groups - February 26, 2014

Common Cause Urges FCC to Reclassify Broadband and Protect Open Internet - February 19, 2014

Proposed Comcast-Time Warner Cable Deal Is Affront to Public Interest - February 13, 2014

Common Cause Statement on Introduction of the Fair Elections Now Act - February 12, 2014

Congress, President Must Staff Election Assistance Commission - February 12, 2014

Common Cause Statement on Introduction of the Government by the People Act - February 5, 2014

Common Cause Urges Ethics Probe of Rep. Michael Grimm - January 29, 2014

Common Cause Statement on the State of the Union Message - January 28, 2014